What "Carrying Costs" Actually Means
When people think about selling land, they usually think about the sale price and maybe a commission. What they don't think about is everything that happens between the day a "For Sale" sign goes up and the day a deed actually gets recorded. That gap can be six months. It can be two years. I've seen Vermont parcels sit on the market for three years or longer, especially raw acreage without road frontage or with some kind of complication.
Every month a parcel sits unsold, it's still costing the owner money. Not a lot in any single month, maybe, but it adds up in ways that surprise people when they finally sit down and do the math. This article is that math.
Property Taxes Don't Pause for a Listing
This is the big one, and it's the one people forget about because the bill doesn't change whether the land is listed or not. Vermont property taxes on land run anywhere from a few hundred dollars a year on a small rural lot to several thousand on a larger parcel, depending on the town, the acreage, and whether it's enrolled in Current Use.
If you're carrying $1,500 a year in property tax and your listing takes eighteen months to produce a buyer, that's $2,250 gone before you ever see a closing table. Nobody hands that money back to you. It's just spent, quietly, while you wait.
And if the land is enrolled in Vermont's Current Use program, there's a separate wrinkle worth knowing about, the withdrawal penalty that can apply depending on how the sale unfolds. I've written about that math elsewhere on this site in detail, but the short version for this article is: taxes are a carrying cost even before you get to any Current Use questions, and they run on the town's calendar, not your listing's calendar.
Insurance and Liability You Might Not Have Thought About
Most people don't carry a specific insurance policy on vacant land, but if you do, or if your umbrella policy has a rider for it, that premium keeps running too. More importantly, vacant land that's actively marketed tends to get more foot traffic, more strangers walking it, more ATV riders or hunters who assume nobody's watching. If someone gets hurt on your land while it's for sale, you're the owner of record, and that's a liability exposure that didn't exist when the property was just sitting quietly unlisted.
I've talked to sellers who didn't think about this until a neighbor mentioned seeing unfamiliar trucks parked at the gate every weekend during hunting season. A listing puts your land on more people's radar, for better and for worse.
Maintenance Nobody Sees Until It's Neglected
Land doesn't take care of itself, and buyers notice when it hasn't been. A field that isn't bush-hogged starts growing in with brush inside two or three seasons. A driveway or old logging road that isn't graded gets rutted out by spring runoff. Boundary lines that aren't walked and refreshed get harder to identify, and old blazes fade.
None of this is dramatic on its own, but it costs money to fix, and it costs money to prevent. Mowing a few acres of field once or twice a year might run a few hundred dollars if you're hiring it out. Culvert repair after a bad mud season can run into the thousands. And if you're not local, someone has to coordinate all of this, which usually means either paying a property manager or making the drive yourself, which has its own cost in gas, time, and lost wages if you're taking a day off work.
I've seen Windham County parcels that sat on the market long enough that the access road washed out entirely between listing and closing, and the seller had to pay to fix it before the deal could go through, on top of everything else.
The Commission Math
If you list with a real estate agent, the standard commission on Vermont land runs 6 to 10 percent depending on the brokerage and the parcel type, sometimes higher on smaller or harder-to-move parcels. On a $150,000 land sale, that's $9,000 to $15,000 coming off the top at closing. That's not a "hidden" cost exactly, it's usually disclosed in the listing agreement, but people tend to think about it as a percentage rather than a dollar figure, and the dollar figure is what actually leaves your pocket.
Some agents also ask sellers to contribute toward marketing costs, professional photos, drone footage, or a survey if one doesn't already exist. A boundary survey on a larger or oddly shaped parcel can run $3,000 to $8,000 or more, and it's often the seller who fronts that cost before there's even a buyer.
Time Is a Cost Too
This is the one that's hardest to put a number on but is often the biggest cost of all. Every month your land sits unsold is a month you're not doing something else with that money. If you sold today and put the proceeds into almost anything else, even a basic savings account, you'd be earning something. Instead, the money is tied up in an asset that's costing you to hold.
For people managing an inherited property, a parcel from a family estate, or land they're only holding because they haven't gotten around to selling it, this is also an emotional and administrative cost. Every year the land isn't sold is another year of tax bills to track, another year of "who's dealing with this" conversations at Thanksgiving, another year of paperwork sitting in a folder somewhere. That's real, even if it doesn't show up on a spreadsheet.
A Windham County Example
Here's a real pattern I've seen play out, with details adjusted for privacy. A family in southern Vermont inherited about 55 acres of mixed woodland in Windham County, no structures, decent road frontage on a town-maintained road, but back from any village center. They listed it with a local agent at $185,000, a fair number for the area given comparable sales.
The listing sat. Land like this, without water frontage or view lots cleared, moves slowly, especially outside the spring and summer buying season. Over the next two years, here's roughly what it cost them:
- Property taxes: about $2,100 a year, enrolled in Current Use, so about $4,200 total over two years
- Bush-hogging the old field twice a year to keep it from growing in: roughly $1,600 total
- One culvert repair after a spring washout: about $2,200
- A survey requested by an early prospective buyer who ultimately didn't close: $4,500
- Two price reductions, first to $174,000, then to $162,000, as the listing aged
By the time the property sold, the family had spent close to $12,500 in direct carrying costs, on top of accepting a price about $23,000 lower than the original list. The commission at closing, at 8 percent of $162,000, was another $12,960. All told, the gap between what they thought they'd net at listing and what actually landed in their account was well over $45,000.
None of that is unusual. It's just not visible until someone adds it up.
Price Reductions and the Long Tail
Land that doesn't sell in the first season almost always gets a price reduction, sometimes more than one. Buyers watching the market see a listing's age and often use it as leverage, assuming there's something wrong with the parcel or that the seller is getting anxious. Sometimes that's true, sometimes it isn't, but the perception itself becomes a cost. A parcel that's been listed for two years typically sells for less, relative to its original ask, than one that sells in the first three months, even when nothing about the land itself has changed.
What This Adds Up To
Put it together and the real cost of listing isn't just the commission at the end. It's:
- Property taxes for every month the land sits, sometimes with Current Use complications layered in
- Maintenance and upkeep to keep the land presentable and access usable
- Insurance and liability exposure from increased foot traffic
- Survey, marketing, or repair costs that may not lead anywhere
- Price erosion from sitting on the market too long
- The opportunity cost of money that's tied up instead of working for you
- The time and mental energy of managing all of it, often from a distance
None of this means listing is always the wrong choice. Some land, especially unique parcels with strong road frontage or development potential, does best going through a broker who can find the right buyer at the right price. But for a lot of ordinary Vermont land, especially older woodland, camp lots, or inherited parcels without a lot of complications, the carrying costs of a long listing process eat into the number a seller actually walks away with in a way that's rarely discussed up front.
The Alternative
This is exactly why I buy land directly, for cash, without listings, agents, or a marketplace process. When I make an offer, I'm accounting for the condition of the land as it sits today, and we can close in a matter of weeks rather than months or years. There's no six month wait while property taxes accrue, no survey you have to front the cost for, no commission coming off the top, and no mowing bill in July for a field you're trying to sell.
It's not the right fit for every seller or every parcel. But if you're weighing a listing against a straightforward cash sale, it's worth running the actual numbers on your specific property, not just the sale price, but everything it would cost you to carry it while you wait for a buyer to show up.
If you own land in Vermont and want to see what a no-obligation cash offer looks like, reach out. I'll walk the numbers with you honestly, whether or not it ends up being the right path for your land.